Buzz Break Battle: 2015 Panini Alabama football vs. 2015 Panini Ohio State football (blaster boxes)

ohiostate-alabamaFrom time to time, Buzz will break a box of something and post the results here. Like this and want to see more? Or maybe there’s a box you’d want to see busted? Send Buzz an email at BlowoutBuzz@blowoutcards.com.

The boxes: 2015 Panini Alabama Crimson Tide football cards vs. 2015 Panini Ohio State Buckeyes football cards (blaster boxes)
Where to buy: 
Check Panini’s webstore for NCAA cards from 2015-16.

s-l500-2ALABAMA
Packs per box: 10
Cards per pack: 8
Cards in this box: 80
Base set completion: 63 of 80 (79 percent)
Duplicates: 12

Notables on base cards – Big Al, DeMeco Ryans, Eddie Lacy, Latrell Sprewell, Joe Namath, John Hannah, Julio Jones, Mo Williams, Mark Ingram, Robert Horry, Ozzie Newsome, A.J. McCarron, Amari Cooper, Antonio McDyess

s-l1600OHIO STATE
Packs per box: 10
Cards per pack: 8
Cards in this box: 80
Base set completion: 49 of 49 (100 percent)
Duplicates: 27

Notables on base cards – Brutus Buckeye, D’Angelo Russell, Cris Carter, Evan Turner, James Laurinaitis, Jim Jackson, Paul Warfield, Rutherford B. Hayes, Ted Ginn Jr., A.J. Hawk

img_6824

ALABAMA
Insert/short-print cards: 4 (see more in gallery below)
Silver parallel (2) – Mo Williams, Jerrell Harris
Honors (1) – A.J. McCarron
Honors Silver (1) – A.J. McCarron (/99)

img_6826

Autographs/Memorabilia: 1
Crimson Tide Memorabilia (1) – Amari Cooper

img_6808

OHIO STATE
Insert/short-print cards: 3 (see more in gallery below)
Silver parallel (2) – Evan Spencer, Corey Linsley
Honors (1) – A.J. Hawk

img_6807

Autographs/Memorabilia: 1
Buckeyes Autographs (1) – Michael Bennett

ALABAMA
Product Grade:
 A-
Box Grade:
 A-
Fun Grade: B

OHIO STATE
Product Grade:
 B-
Box Grade:
 B
Fun Grade: C+

What’s Buzz-worthy: This year’s top two college teams in the rankings face off here on cardboard via these $20 boxes and, well, it’s not an easy comparison and it’s one that’s curious at times. … Ohio State has plenty of football history, but this smaller set is loaded with more recent gridiron players in a set that doesn’t include any former Buckeyes baseball players like Frank Howard or Nick Swisher or even legendary football names such as Archie Griffin, Eddie George, Chris Spielman, Orlando Pace, Vic Janowicz or Howard Cassady. … Alabama counters with a larger set and includes stars from the three major sports with the likes of Joe Namath, Eddie Lacy, Latrell Sprewell, John Hannah, Julio Jones, Robert Horry, Ozzie Newsome, Amari Cooper and plenty more along with a crop of younger, more current players. … Neither set includes any iconic coaches (you can probably think of a few for these schools) and each could easily include many more iconic players who went on to successful pro careers after big college successes. … Each blaster box includes either one autograph or memorabilia card — we saw one of each type here — along with a pair of parallels and an insert. Alabama delivered slightly more with a parallel of an insert, too. … The Alabama set includes three memorabilia cards and 12 autos on its checklist, while the Ohio State set includes five memorabilia cards and eight autos. The edge there probably goes to Alabama with the depth and names like A.J. McCarron, Eddie Lacy and T.J. Yeldon on the auto checklist.

So … who wins overall with these boxes? Alabama delivered better name value, while Ohio State delivered the full set. The Crimson Tide set just feels closer to comprehensive, though both could easily be updated to add a second series. These were both part of the first wave of college releases in 2015 and more schools were recently released, though none have yet had a second wave. On cardboard, the Crimson Tide wins.

Follow Buzz on Twitter @BlowoutBuzz or send email to BlowoutBuzz@blowoutcards.com. 

>> Click here to buy cards on BlowoutCards.com

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s